Taking Off the Mask: A Book Club Guide to The Gift of Being Yourself
The Gift of
Being Yourself
that I may know thee.
About the Book
Christians talk a lot about knowing God, but how often do we talk about knowing ourselves? David Benner, a psychologist and spiritual director, argues that the two can't be separated: we come to know who we really are by knowing God, and we come to know God more deeply as we stop hiding from ourselves.
In six short chapters (about 128 pages), Benner invites us to notice the masks we wear, name the "false self" we've built for safety and approval, and step into the true self God created and loves. It's small enough to read in a weekend and rich enough to chew on for a year. It's the second book in his Spiritual Journey trilogy, alongside Surrender to Love and Desiring God's Will.
The True Self Spritz
Simple, honest ingredients with nothing to hide. Deep blue like the cover, with a little sparkle.
- 1 oz honey-lavender syrup (equal parts honey & hot water, steeped with 1 tsp dried lavender for 10 minutes, then strained)
- 3 oz fresh lemonade
- A handful of muddled blueberries
- Top with sparkling water
- Garnish: lemon wheel and a lavender sprig
Muddle the blueberries in a glass, add syrup and lemonade, fill with ice, and top with bubbles. Make it a cocktail: add 1½ oz gin.
Key Ideas to Know
| The False Self | The identity we build to feel safe, admired, or in control. Benner says it's rooted in the lie that we are what we do, what we have, or what others think of us. |
| The True Self | Who we are "in Christ": not a better version we build ourselves, but the self God already knows and loves, received as a gift. |
| Knowing vs. Knowing About | Information about God isn't the same as knowing God personally. Transformation happens through lived, experiential encounter. |
| Deeply Loved First | We can only face the hard truths about ourselves once we're secure in God's love. Love makes honesty safe. |
| Our Shadow | The parts of ourselves we'd rather not see. Benner encourages us to bring them into the light instead of hiding them. |
Chapter by Chapter
Benner lays the foundation: real spiritual growth happens only when we know God and ourselves deeply, and each kind of knowing feeds the other. This isn't head knowledge or facts collected about God. It's personal, experiential knowing that changes us from the inside, the way we know a close friend rather than a famous stranger.
Before we can safely look at ourselves, we have to know we are loved. Benner explains that knowing God starts with experiencing His unconditional love, not earning it. He invites readers to meet Jesus through prayerful, imaginative reading of the Gospel stories, placing ourselves in the scene and letting love sink in deeper than belief.
Self-knowledge begins with curiosity and honest attention instead of judgment. Benner encourages us to notice our feelings, desires, reactions, and even our bodies, and to welcome what we find. The goal isn't navel-gazing; it's showing up before God as we actually are, not as we think we should be.
Here Benner gets brave. He asks us to face our shadow and the particular pattern of sin we tend toward, the thing beneath the things. He introduces the Enneagram as one tool for spotting it. The good news woven through: we can face the hard truth because we are deeply loved sinners, not disqualified ones.
Every one of us builds a false self, a version designed to protect us and win approval. Benner traces it back to the garden, when Adam and Eve first hid and covered themselves. The false self rests on a lie: that we are what we do, what we have, or what others think of us. Recognizing our masks is the first step to setting them down.
Our true self is found hidden in Christ, the self God dreamed of when He made us. It isn't something we manufacture; it's received as we let the false self die. Benner shows how living from that identity frees us to discover our vocation, so that what we do flows out of who we are rather than the other way around.
Benner closes by reminding us that becoming ourselves is a lifelong journey, not a one-time breakthrough. Our identity keeps unfolding as we walk with God, one honest, loved step at a time.
Discussion Questions
- When someone asks "Tell me about yourself," what do you usually lead with: your job, your family, your roles? What does that reveal?
- Which line or idea from the book has stayed with you most since you closed it?
- Benner separates knowing about God from knowing God personally. Where in your life does your faith live mostly in your head, and where has it reached your heart?
- He suggests we can't face ourselves honestly until we feel deeply loved. Do you believe God loves you as you are right now, not as you hope to become? What makes that hard to believe?
- Augustine prayed to know himself so that he might know God. Why do you think so few of us pray that way?
- Is self-discovery selfish, or is it a spiritual discipline? Where did your own answer to that come from?
- Benner invites us to notice our emotions instead of judging them. Which emotion do you most often push down or explain away?
- What's one thing about yourself you've only learned through a hard season, a close friend, or a painful mistake?
- What "costume" do you put on most often: the capable one, the helper, the fun one, the one who has it together? When did you first start wearing it?
- Our false self is often built from good things like achievement, approval, or being needed. Which good thing have you leaned on for your identity?
- Is there a place, or a person, where you can take the mask off completely? What makes it safe there?
- Benner describes the true self as a gift we receive, not a project we complete. How does that land for someone who loves a good to-do list?
- How would your relationships (marriage, friendships, family) change if you showed up as your true self more often?
- Is there a calling or dream you set aside because it didn't fit the person you thought you were supposed to be?
- Some Christian reviewers love this book and some are cautious. They worry it leans more on psychology and the mystics than on Scripture and the cross. Where did you find yourself agreeing or pushing back as you read?
- How do we pursue self-knowledge without making ourselves the center of the story?
- Finish this sentence: "The truest thing about me is…"
- What's one mask you'd like to set down this month, and how can this group pray for you?
Take It Home: A 15-Minute Practice
Benner encourages a daily prayerful review, a gentle look back over your day with God. Try it each evening this week:
- Be still. Ask God to show you your day through His loving eyes.
- Give thanks. Notice one gift from today, however small.
- Notice. When did you feel most like yourself? When did you reach for a mask?
- Receive. Let yourself be loved, not judged, for what you see.
- Look ahead. Ask for grace to be your true self tomorrow.
What Other Readers Are Saying
Calls it self-discovery seen through the lens of God, and loved the practical prayer exercises, including the daily review.
Found Chapter 4 especially helpful for spotting a projected false identity, but felt the book leans on mystics like Thomas Merton and underplays the cross.
Appreciates the core message that God strips away the false self, but wanted more theology and less psychology. Suggests reading with discernment.
Sources
- Benner, David G. The Gift of Being Yourself: The Sacred Call to Self-Discovery, Expanded Edition. IVP Formatio, 2015.
- InterVarsity Press: book page and table of contents
- Chats with Candice: "The Gift of Being Yourself"
- MissionTools: Resource review
- Mike Leake: Review of The Gift of Being Yourself
- Psalm 139:23–24, King James Version.
Comments
Post a Comment
Comments?